ArticlesReader.com Menu
Newest Articles
Most Viewed Articles
ArticlesReader.com RSS
Submit Article
Login
Signup
Search the articles

Articles Main Categories
Advice
Animals
Automobiles
Business
Career
Communications
Computer Programming
Computers
Entertainment
Environment
Family
Fashion
Finance
Food
Health & Medical
Home & Garden
Humor
Internet Business
Internet Marketing
Legal
Leisure & Recreation
Marketing
Other
Politics
Reference & Education
Religion
Self Improvement
Sports
Technology & Science
Travel
Writing
Subscribe
Receive alert message from us when new articles submitted to our site for free.

Enter your name

Enter your email

Syndicate

















Related Products
Home::Web Design

Separate text-only version? No thanks!

Author : Trenton Moss
In an attempt to make their sites accessible to all, more and more websites are now offering text-only versions of their sites. With the huge number of inaccessible websites out there, any attempt to make a website accessible to one and all is highly commendable.



But is text-only the way forward? The W3C have this to say about alternative accessible sites:



And if all else fails... If, after best efforts, you cannot create an accessible page, provide a link to an alternative page.



Hmmm... so according to the W3C a separate accessible site is OK, but they do use some pretty strong language to suggest that this should be avoided wherever possible. They're probably right too, given the disadvantages of going down the text-only route:



Text-only version may not be accessible



The most ironic thing about text-only versions, is that often they don't even offer full accessibility. This could be for a number of reasons, two of the most common being:



- Non-descriptive link text: Visually impaired Internet users can browse web pages by tabbing from one link to the next. Link text such as ‘click here' and ‘more', which may feature in a text-only version, won't make any sense to them when doing this.



- Inaccessible forms: For optimal accessibility, prompt text should be assigned to its form item, using the label for attribute. To check for this, a flashing cursor should appear in each form box when the text next to it is clicked.



Primary website may be inaccessible to site visitors



One of the myths of web accessibility is that accessibility is only about blind and disabled users. Accessibility is actually about everyone being able to access your website, both disabled and non-disabled, regardless of the browsing technology they're using.



For example, users accessing your website through WebTV, mobile phones, and PDAs, which have limited support for large images, Flash and JavaScript, may not be able to access your site. Don't underestimate the importance of this: in 2008 alone an estimated 58 million PDAs will be sold (source: http://www.etforecasts.com/pr/pr0603.htm) and one third of the world's population will own a wireless device (source: http://www.clickz.com/stats/sectors/wireless/article.php/10094_950001).



Lost branding opportunity



Some users may only need to make small adjustments to your site in order to be able to effectively use it. For example, a site visitor who needs to slightly resize the text on your site may have to use the text-only version if you don't allow this is the main version. This person then won't be exposed to your online image and branding, which you've undoubtedly spent so long developing.



Large time and money investment



Creating a separate accessible version can obviously represents an extremely large time and money investment. This can be offset if the site is database-driven, although there's still a time investment involved in setting up this alternative version - time that could have instead been spent making the primary site accessible to all.



Less information



Some text-only versions offer far less information and/or functionality than the primary version of the site. Manchester United's accessible version is a prime example of this: the primary website features over 100 choices in the navigation menu; the accessible version just eight. For a busy webmaster, having to make updates to two versions of the same website can be a huge pain.



If the website is 100% database driven then the separate text-only version will automatically be updated with the primary version of the site. Although database-driven sites are commonplace on the web, it is very rare that every single page is drawn from the database. As such, even with a database-driven site separate versions can often be left behind.



Marginalisation of society



The final point, and perhaps the most important. One of the most famous quotes about accessibility was made by Tim Berners-Lee, the man who invented the Internet:



The power of the Web is in its universality. Access by everyone regardless of disability is an essential aspect.

Creating a separate version for web users with special needs can be seen as just one more way of them being marginalised from every day society. Having a separate accessible version has been famously likened to a restaurant providing a side door down a back alley for disabled customers, because the main entrance has a couple of stairs leading in to the restaurant.



The idea of the Internet is that it's an inclusive medium, which everyone should be able to use and access. Visually impaired individuals particularly can now access a virtually unlimited source of information in a way that would never have been possible.



Text-only? No thanks!



There are therefore so many reasons as to why a separate text-only version isn't a good idea. Additionally, there are a such huge number of benefits to having an accessible website that there's no excuse for not trying to make your main website accessible to everyone.



Certainly many big organisations are now working towards offering accessible websites, which is highly commendable. So come on guys, let's keep working to make sure the Internet is fully inclusive.


Article Source: http://www.articledashboard.com





This article was written by Trenton Moss. He's crazy about web usability and accessibility - so crazy that he went and started his own web usability and accessibility consultancy (Webcredible - www.webcredible.co.uk) to help make the Internet a better place for everyone.





Spam emails More free articles

Related articles


  1. The Top 8 Website Sins Part Two
  2. The Top 8 Website Sins Part One
  3. 10 seconds is all it takes (How to grab the attention of your audience with your web site)
  4. So Youre Hiring a Web DesignerYou Have the Right to Demand these 7 Perks
  5. 6 Design Flaws Newbie Web Designers Make: Fool Everyone Into Thinking You Know What You're Doing
  6. Excellently Constructed Websites
  7. Web Designers Beware!
  8. Quality Website Design At An Affordable Price
  9. Website Colors That Turn Off Your Customers
  10. What The Font? Understanding Typefaces On The Web
  11. Freelancers Bite Back!
  12. Web Design: Should You Hire Someone or Do It Yourself?
  13. Branding Web Strategy Mistakes - Brand Identity Guru
  14. Web-Safe Fonts for Your Site
  15. Web Designing Tips
  16. Good Websites Stand Out From The Masses Of Boring, Hard To Travel Sites
  17. Testament To Testimonials
  18. Reach Out To Billions
  19. Every Website is a Human Beings Attempt at Achieving a Goal or Obtaining Happiness
  20. Give People What They Want And Watch Your Profits Soar!
  21. You Too Can Have an Amazing Website
  22. The Seven Deadly Sins of Web Business Design
  23. 10 Nifty Ways to Prolong Your Visitors at Your Website
  24. Website Design: Redecorate Your Web Site To Increase Sales
  25. Service Professions: Does Your Website Follow These 5 Simple Rules For Getting More Clients?
More related feeds
Separate text-only version? No thanks!
Article argues that a separate text-only version is a really bad idea. Find out why...

Better Website Development: Separate Textonly Version No Thanks
Separate Textonly Version No Thanks. Writen by Trenton Moss. In an attempt to make their sites accessible to all, more and more websites are now offering text-only versions of their sites. With the huge number of inaccessible websites ...

News Flash: Three New Expansion Scenarios Announced at Vana'diel ...
Concurrent with the regular version updates, the new expansions are being developed as a with a “novelette” approach. Indeed, a separate development team has been established specifically for these new expansions. Additional Scenarios? ...

Ecology Quotes !!! - Care2 News Network
Wildness reminds us what it means to be human, what we are connected to rather than what we are separate from." ~ Terry Tempest Williams "Energy Policy will be and should be driven by environmental policy in the future." ~ Timothy Wirth ...

Teching It Easy: Windows Vista & 7: Instant and Social ...
There are no clear differences between the sign in screen in version 9.0 compared to 8.5. Your personalization such as themes and color scheme is retained if you upgrade from a previous version. Signing in for the first time you can ...

Windows Live FolderShare Team Blog: Windows Live Sync replacing ...
More folders and files - sync up to 20 folders with 20000 files each. Integration with Windows Live ID - no more extra sign-in stuff to remember. Integration with the Recyle Bin - no more separate Trash folder to fiddle with. ...

Pakistani neuroscientist unable to stand trial declared ment ...
Lord Nazeer has also submitted that Prisoner 650 has no separate toilet facilities and has to attend to her bathing and movements in full view of the other. In the course of Yvonne Ridley’s investigation, she came to call Prisoner 650 ...

DOLPHIN ALERT FROM BLUEVOICE.ORG - Care2 News Network
Thursday November 13, 2008, 2:07 pm OMG-THESE PEOPLE IN JAPAN & CHINA KNOW NO BOUNDS OF CRUELTY TO ALL THEY COME IN CONTACT WITH--THIS IS SO SAD FOR THE FAMILY ORIENTED AND LOVING DOLPHINS! THANK YOU SOPHIA--WILL SEND EMAILS & FORWARD! ...

MARIA DAINES: SONGS FOR THE ANIMALS--SHE PUTS THE ANIMAL'S S ...
Thank you so much for this post. I listened to some of the songs, and yes, they bring tears to your eyes. Such a compassionate singer, and for such a worthy cause. Bless you, Maria and Paul. and Brenda, for bringing this to Care2. thank ...

NewsBin Community Forums :: View topic - Version 5.50 Beta 8 ...
Reworked Read Post Body to no longer use a database. Doing an RPB (ctrl-r) on a post will now create a .txt file and will be displayed in the Files tab. Anyway, what I want is to be able to put a large number of text-only posts without ...

 

 

2007 articlesreader.com - All Rights Reserved