|
Home::Technology & Science
Deceptive Public Speakers
Author : Clive Simpkins
Deceptive Public Speakers and presenters - or just the blind leading the blind?
A disappointing deception is being perpetrated in the so-called public speaking and presenting arena. For years its been a (now fading, thank God) norm for companies to have a motivational speaker at annual marketing, sales and other conferences. Being a veteran public speaker and founding member of the National Speakers Association of SA (NSASA), I need to declare an interest. The purpose of this article is to 1) Alert relevant parties to the canned nature of what they may be getting for their speaker money and 2) Hopefully save some young wanna-be speakers from going down a highly inappropriate and ersatz road.
My opinion of the role of an authentic public speaker is that one takes a brief to get enough information to really understand the audience and the intended outcome of the assignment or conference. You then custom-craft something or tweak an existing suitable presentation for the event and then deliver that material in an engaging, and hopefully also professionally entertaining way.
What triggered this article can only be described as a Damascene experience. Biblical-proportion scales fell from my eyes when I realised that the majority of the self-proclaimed top speakers around the world have moved out of public speaking into public parroting and parody. And some South African speakers are now at risk of falling into the same trap. Its the equivalent if you will of Madonna, Josh Groban or Placido Domingo lip-synching. Why the analogy? Well, because it appears that many of these speakers learn off-pat every single word of what they say on stage. Worse, they rehearse, memorise and do the same with every vocal inflection, movement and gesture - including the spontaneously arched eyebrow and the pregnant but utterly contrived pause.
I studied speech and drama under the eagle eye of the redoubtable Rita Maas-Phillips in Cape Town. We trainee thespians became very familiar with the genius of Constantin Stanislavsky. He was the renowned director of the Moscow Arts Theatre and the father of method acting which was subsequently adopted - to singular effect - by discerning movie actors. Seasoned live theatre actors had long benefitted. In method acting, you become the character. So when Daniel Day-Lewis played the lead role in My Left Foot, he would sustain his on-camera character even off-set. If you were to play Quasimodo, you would continue to walk, eat, speak and interact as you believe the legendary hunchback of Notre Dame might have. What the audience got was as we say in South Africa, die ware Jakob the real thing, the Makoya!
It seems that inappropriate competitiveness and a desperate need for acclaim by peers and public has shifted public speaking at the top end of the (former) art, into an exercise in mimicry. Parrot-fashion learning and highly manipulative NLP-driven stage movements hold sway. I cottoned on to this when I saw one of these characters demonstrating so-called stagecraft to some fledgling speakers. Each time, he replicated the same few lines, inflections and movements with terrifying and mathematical precision. It was like watching a rewind and slo-mo replay of a sequence on TV. He proudly proclaimed that this was how he managed to get a predictable and consistent result from an audience, time after time.
This is regretfully, high-school speaking competition or Eisteddfod-type memorization. At its worst, neurolinguistic manipulation. Its not even decent amateur acting. Because although an actor will commit to heart, her or his lines, the nuances and variations in each performance will give it memorable impact and make it art. But the parrots of the speaking circuit dont allow themselves even that leeway. They produce a clone of their performance at function after function and at venue after venue.
All good communicating on a topic will always of course have to incorporate the skeleton on certain aspects. So yes, there may often be a degree of repetition. But it will be differently phrased and delivered each and every time because of the unique audience energy, dynamic and interaction or, lack of it!
So why am I so disturbed by this galloping trend in the public speaking arena? Simply because its an absolute waste and abuse of what can, with the right mindset and understanding, be a speaking gift. When you have a good sense of the issues youd like to explore in a presentation, youve got a sequence or line of thought and youve got your support material (if required) together, then comes the time for the real art.
The first, more commercial approach will be to source, structure the material, have a very clear sense of where youre going and know how long the presentation or talk will take. But you intentionally keep open your receptivity to subtle audience interaction (not necessarily spoken, but a vibe) and feedback in the form of engagement, response and so on, driving an element of your presentation. This can happen even with a typical non-interactive keynote address.
The second and highest form of communicating - is doing all the required prep but then trusting to the universe, God, your higher consciousness, intuition, the Ancestors, your Muse or whatever you wish to call it, to use you as an instrument to bring something special and of value to your listeners. Yes, even though it may be a business presentation, it can have an edge that is unique and different.
When youre appropriately ego-free and understand that youre only ever the instrument or co-player through which such a message will be delivered - but never the sole author - then amazing, sustainable transformation can and does take place. People are affected and infected by the integrity and congruence of your message. Youll potentially have lower demand appeal, because the undiscerning masses are mainly looking for a quick fix. And there are innumerable frauds out there just waiting to serve up their version of a just add water and stir formula. Dont listen to cynics who say that such integrity-based speaking, presenting or communicating isnt possible or even desirable. Rather, talk with people for whom it is a norm rather than the exception and explore your real speaking and presenting potential.
The role of intuition shouldnt be underestimated. For those who respect the gift, there will be the sub-conscious reading of energies and needs emanating from an individual or the audience. You may recall afterwards, that you used examples or analogies that you hadnt for years. Or that you went very high disclosure on personal-experience based and therefore healing information - because you were functioning authentically. You had prepared, you might well have rehearsed to ensure you honour the precise time allocated. But you spoke from the core of your being, knowing that it was not you alone speaking, but you in synch and tandem with the Wise Ones. Theres nothing mystical about this. Its about choosing to operate at another and much more powerful level. Youll know and feel the difference and so will discerning audiences.
By Clive Simpkins June 2005
clive@imbizo.com
May be used freely with appropriate attribution
Also published in tomorrowtoday.biz newsletter
www.marketingweb.co.za
www.imbizo.com
About the Author
Clive is a marketing and communications strategist and published book author. His speciality is facilitating sustainable change in individuals and organizations. Website: www.imbizo.com Spam emails More free articles Related articles
|
More related feeds |
Mercatornet: The change they forgot about: education
The first change is to get rid of the deceptive word “public”, as in “public education”. “Public” means “devoted to the general or nation’s welfare.” Right now 88 percent of the nation’s 50 million children are in the state-supported ...CL&P Blog: Interesting Explanation for the Lesser Depression
The speaker then observed that it's not surprising when a fire breaks out at the home. The theory does explain why so many decisions that have since appeared to be self-destructive were made. I suspect that it will ultimately not stand ... The young and the bold - Bhutan Observer - Bhutan News
Youth councils are a popular and powerful way to promote young people’s participation in local government, helping them: Learn first hand about how government works; Gain leadership experience and new skills, such as public speaking and ... Truth to Power: The Harper Conservatives and the Charest Liberals
"We know that the economic statement of Jean Charest and Monique Jérôme-Forget was a deceptive document, full of erroneous data and modified for partisan purposes. We are dealing with the second major manipulation in an official ... Public Speaking
But they do need to stop the government from quoting vacancy rates based on deceptive data leading the public to think there are beds available for the people they see on the street. I talked to one of my clients earlier. ... speech writing
students are exposed to speech writing exercises in public speaking courses. in an academic setting, speech writing prepares an individual to notice issues, conflict and realize their internal powerful potential through elaborate and ... » How to Succeed at Online Dating Learning Is Free: Need an answer ...
Online dating is a popular new tool for initiating romantic relationships, although recent research and media reports suggest that it may also be fertile ground for deception. Unlike previous studies that rely solely on self-report data ... WTHR - Indianapolis News Weather -Rokita says deceptive letter isn ...
... color, religion, national origin, age, sex, marital status, disability, military status, citizenship or any other legally-protected status in accordance with applicable local, state and federal law. Jobs at WTHR EEO Public File Report. deceptive public speakers
a disappointing deception is being perpetrated in the so-called public speaking and presenting arena. for years it’s been a (now fading, thank god) ‘norm’ for companies to have a ‘motivational’ speaker at annual marketing, ... Truthdig - Reports - Chevron in the White House
Even the ancient Romans, who new a thing or two about public speaking, warned against the dangers of getting carried away with rhetoric. Without real substance, it just becomes so much hot air and can be very damaging. Report this ...
|
|
|
