ArticlesReader.com Menu
Newest Articles
Most Viewed Articles
ArticlesReader.com RSS
Submit Article
Login
Signup
Search the articles

Articles Main Categories
Advice
Animals
Automobiles
Business
Career
Communications
Computer Programming
Computers
Entertainment
Environment
Family
Fashion
Finance
Food
Health & Medical
Home & Garden
Humor
Internet Business
Internet Marketing
Legal
Leisure & Recreation
Marketing
Other
Politics
Reference & Education
Religion
Self Improvement
Sports
Technology & Science
Travel
Writing
Subscribe
Receive alert message from us when new articles submitted to our site for free.

Enter your name

Enter your email

Syndicate

















Related Products
Home::Mark Crisp

Against The Top Down Approach To Picking Stocks

Author : Geoff Gannon -
If you have heard fund managers talk about the way they invest, you know a great many employ a top down approach. First, they decide how much of their portfolio to allocate to stocks and how much to allocate to bonds. At this point, they may also decide upon the relative mix of foreign and domestic securities. Next, they decide upon the industries to invest in. It is not until all these decisions have been made that they actually get down to analyzing any particular securities. If you think logically about this approach for but a moment, you will recognize how truly foolish it is.



A stock’s earnings yield is the inverse of its P/E ratio. So, a stock with a P/E ratio of 25 has an earnings yield of 4%, while a stock with a P/E ratio of 8 has an earnings yield of 12.5%. In this way, a low P/E stock is comparable to a high – yield bond.



Now, if these low P/E stocks had very unstable earnings or carried a great deal of debt, the spread between the long bond yield and the earnings yield of these stocks might be justified. However, many low P/E stocks actually have more stable earnings than their high multiple kin. Some do employ a great deal of debt. Still, within recent memory, one could find a stock with an earnings yield of 8 – 12%, a dividend yield of 3- 5%, and literally no debt, despite some of the lowest bond yields in half a century. This situation could only come about if investors shopped for their bonds without also considering stocks. This makes about as much sense as shopping for a van without also considering a car or truck.



All investments are ultimately cash to cash operations. As such, they should be judged by a single measure: the discounted value of their future cash flows. For this reason, a top down approach to investing is nonsensical. Starting your search by first deciding upon the form of security or the industry is like a general manager deciding upon a left handed or right handed pitcher before evaluating each individual player. In both cases, the choice is not merely hasty; it’s false. Even if pitching left handed is inherently more effective, the general manager is not comparing apples and oranges; he’s comparing pitchers. Whatever inherent advantage or disadvantage exists in a pitcher’s handedness can be reduced to an ultimate value (e.g., run value). For this reason, a pitcher’s handedness is merely one factor (among many) to be considered, not a binding choice to be made. The same is true of the form of security. It is neither more necessary nor more logical for an investor to prefer all bonds over all stocks (or all retailers over all banks) than it is for a general manager to prefer all lefties over all righties. You needn’t determine whether stocks or bonds are attractive; you need only determine whether a particular stock or bond is attractive. Likewise, you needn’t determine whether “the market” is undervalued or overvalued; you need only determine that a particular stock is undervalued. If you’re convinced it is, buy it – the market be damned!



Clearly, the most prudent approach to investing is to evaluate each individual security in relation to all others, and only to consider the form of security insofar as it affects each individual evaluation. A top down approach to investing is an unnecessary hindrance. Some very smart investors have imposed it upon themselves and overcome it; but, there is no need for you to do the same.


Article Source: http://www.articledashboard.com





Geoff Gannon writes a daily value investing blog and produces a twice weekly (half hour) value investing podcast at Gannon on Investing.





Spam emails More free articles

Related articles


  1. So You'd Like To DayTrade(Or Not)
  2. The Golden Pendulum Formula
  3. Understanding Option Trading, Simply
  4. Penny Stock Strategies
  5. Of Stocks, Stockholders And Stock Market
  6. Stock Indexes: The Inside Story
  7. Stock Brokers -- Just The Facts
  8. Stock Markets Of The World
  9. Learn Stock Trading From Playing Poker
  10. Penny Stocks - Turn Your Pennies Into Dollars
  11. You buy and price falls,you sell and price rises.
  12. 3 Steps To Profitable Stock Picking
  13. Wall Street, October 1929
  14. Stock market guide
  15. Dealing With Market Corrections: Ten DoÂ’s and Don'ts
  16. The Myth of the Earnings Yield
  17. The Friendly Trend - Technical vs. Fundamental Analysis
  18. On Volatility and Risk
  19. Your Sure Way to Lasting Success in Trading
  20. Winning Traders - What They Have In Common
  21. Against The Top Down Approach To Picking Stocks
  22. Trading Using Multiple Time Frames
  23. Is Day Trading For A Living Your Cup Of Tea?
  24. Use the Power of Autosuggestion in the Stock Market
  25. Investor Awareness Campaigns: A Look at the Other Side
More related feeds
'Hot' stock pick for Wall Street's nuclear winter
Preventing nuclear and radiological material from being smuggled into the United States has become a top national priority in recent years. In 2005, the White House created the Domestic Nuclear Detection Office at Homeland Security to ...

Approach China Medical With Caution - Stockpickr! Your Source for ...
These stocks recently were trading at, respectively, $52.78, down 3.2%; $5.98, down 8.7%; $27.07, down 2.6%; $30.84, down 1.2%; and $57.90, down 0.3%. For more on the value of knowing what you own, visit TheStreet.com's Investing A-to-Z ...

Political Punch
We saw a very good 8 years of new jobs being created, stock market soaring, even a balanced budget. I don't care that Obama is picking a lot of Clinton people. It seems to be a good move. I'll take it if it turns this economy around. ...

BoomTown Pick for Microsoft Digital Head: Qi Lu (Yes, the Former ...
BoomTown Pick for Microsoft Digital Head: Qi Lu (Yes, the ... - Yesterday, BoomTown opined that Microsoft was nearing a decision on who would become the head of its digital efforts . And, according to several sources and some puzzling ...

Cherry Pick Top Talent Away from Rivals | BNET
Companies looking to pick up talent also need to think strategically about using the Web to recruit. Build an online relationship with coveted employees before calling or interviewing, says John Sullivan, a management professor at San ...

Dow Jumps About 500 Points on Geithner Pick - Market Overview * US ...
A late-day selloff sent stocks down Monday, back up Tuesday then into a downward spiral Wednesday and Thursday that saw the Dow break through 8000 one day and 7882 the next day as Congress hit the brakes on the auto bailout and ...

Apple stock looks ripe for the picking
There will come a time when Apple stock will no longer be bogged down by its sector. I don’t know exactly when that day is but it's coming. As investors ask, where can I make money? Apple offers the best answer in the market. ...

THE WEEKLY GLOBAL INVESTOR: US STOCKS RALLY ON FED'S GEITHNER PICK!
The financial dictatorial powers you are asking for from the US Congress will only slow down human progress and in the middle and longer term will only make this systemic risk worse. I know power bestowed by people is hard to relinquish ...

Online Trading & Investment: Broker's Take - 22 Nov 2008
As we are still in the early phase of a recession, we will pick stocks whose earnings are more resilient, such as consumer staples, media, telecoms, and utilities. We will sell on strength asset plays; we expect more downside in asset ...

DISSENTING JUSTICE: One Down, Three to Go: Florida Beats Citadel 70-19
UF closes its season with an annual clash against in-state rival FSU, followed by the SEC Championship Game against Alabama, which currently holds the top spot in the rankings. If the Gators win those two games, they will likely earn a ...

 


 

© 2007 articlesreader.com - All Rights Reserved