|
Home::Entertainment
Do You Download Music Over A File-Sharing Network?
Author : Jason A. Martin
It can be estimated that millions of people around the world share music over a file-sharing network. For this article, I am addressing the issue in America mainly because I am not aware of the laws in other countries. Do you think it is illegal to download music from file-sharing networks? What about music you already own? An important recent court decision will answer these questions directly and you might be surprised.
Recently the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit heard a case against a Chicago woman, Cecilia Gonzalez. Many plaintiffs including BMG, Sony and others brought the case against her. Gonzalez allegedly had downloaded over 1,000 songs through KaZaA—although she admitted to only 30. Keep that number in mind, 30. Many, if not just about all, people who download files over a file-sharing network don’t stop at one file. Thirty files can be reached in minutes to an hour without thought. In fact, it was alleged that Gonzalez downloaded 1,370 songs in just a few weeks, which is an average of 65 songs per day.
If you where caught downloading thirty songs over a file-sharing network, what would your defense be? LetÂ’s look at two specific common defenses and see how a court might react. I have selected two defenses that I feel are most common, because they not only appear in the court case I have referenced, but many others I have surveyed would try to use them as their defense as well.
First Defense: I was simply trying out the songs to see if I liked them and then I planned to buy the ones I liked and erase the ones I donÂ’t. (Simplified: try-before-you-buy)
Judge Eastbrook, one of the judges hearing the Gonzalez case, pointed out that this defense is not valid because one had many avenues to hear music before purchasing. Eastbrook names iTunes, radio, internet radio, Yahoo! Music and others as ways to legally try before buying. If this was going to be your defense, you will lose.
Second Defense: I am only downloading music that I already own.
This seems like a great defense, at first. You already own the music and the law allows you to create a backup copy. Ah, but here is where it goes south. Downloading music you already own is not considered fair use under the U.S. Copyright Law and your action is therefore copyright infringement. See UMG Recordings Inc. v. MP3.com, Inc., 92 F. Supp. 2d 349.
Furthermore, the try-before-you-buy scenario is really blown away by the fact that you no longer need to buy CDÂ’s in whole. iTunes really helped change the legal arena in this respect because a user can both sample songs at their leisure and purchase single songs. The ability to purchase single songs is the big one.
In the end, Gonzalez lost her case. The thirty songs, that would have cost $29.70 at iTunes, will end up costing her $22,500 in damages—imagine what it would be if the plaintiffs had pushed for a decision on all 1,370 songs. She was given the opportunity to settle for $3,500 before going to court, which she declined—another bad decision. If you download music over file-sharing networks and are caught, what will be your legal defense?
Article Source: http://www.articledashboard.com
Jason A. Martin is a Journalism Major (Political Science minor) and future law school student. His blog deals with Politics, Media and the Law. You can view it at JasonAMartin.com Subscribe!
Spam emails More free articles Related articles
|
More related feeds |
EMule Pro Ultra - Multiple Unmonitored Downloads Made Possible by ...
It even gets worse if you still download files from the web, which really makes your searches limited and super slow. In 2002, a guy who calls himself Merkur decided that existing peer-to-peer file sharing applications do not have some ...Songbeat: Might be awesome, but might also be illegal. | Big Small ...
And you’d be RIGHT! It’s probably completely illegal! The German company says nothing about the rights for the music other than it’s up to you, the user, to determine if it’s legal for you to download the music. Hooray! ... » ShareTool 1.2.5: Access your Bonjour services securely from ...
ShareTool lets you access all of the Bonjour services on your home network from anywhere in the world. This includes iTunes Music Sharing, Screen Sharing, File Sharing, printing, and more. With ShareTool, you can listen to your entire ... Free Master Kick Download, Master Kick 1.5.0 Download - Once ...
DownloadPlex.com also does not provide download link for software listed on our site from Rapidshare, Megaupload, Yousendit. The download file is obtained directly from the publisher, not from any Peer to Pear file sharing applications ... PowerFolder Pro 3.1.3
PowerFolder 1.0 RC2. PowerFolder is a free tool to synchronize folders over the internet or local network. It can be used to exchange every type of data, for example - documents, photos, music, videos or project files. Download now ... Paul McCartney Doesn't Mind Filesharing - US Rock Radio Network
The debate over file-sharing and it's implications on art has been around for at least since 2001 when the Napster case made headlines throughout the. Midomi Allows you to Search Music Using your Voice by Singing or ...
Midomi is a free iPhone application. And you can download it from iTunes with this direct link. Midomi has lot more features than Shazam and currently our preferred music search app for the iPhone. What do you think about Midomi? ... p2pnet news » Blog Archive » A mockery of reality
Because Joel Tenenbaum allegedly downloaded seven songs from a file-sharing network comprised of millions of his peers doing likewise, the plaintiffs have already imposed upon him process filling a docket sheet running back over years. ... MediaMonkey 3.0.1.1116 - software free download
Create Previews, short samples of audio tracks, that you can use when trying to decide which audio files you want to add to your collection. - Use a Sleep Timer to play your music, gradually fade it over a set period of time, ... Free Neutrinox Robot Controller Download, Neutrinox Robot ...
Free Neutrinox Robot Controller Download, Neutrinox Robot Controller 2.2 Download. Control your RS232 projects through your computer's serial portNeutrinox Robot Controller allows you to control RS232 enabled microchips such as the PIC ...
|
|
|
