ArticlesReader.com Menu
Newest Articles
Most Viewed Articles
ArticlesReader.com RSS
Submit Article
Login
Signup
Search the articles

Articles Main Categories
Advice
Animals
Automobiles
Business
Career
Communications
Computer Programming
Computers
Entertainment
Environment
Family
Fashion
Finance
Food
Health & Medical
Home & Garden
Humor
Internet Business
Internet Marketing
Legal
Leisure & Recreation
Marketing
Other
Politics
Reference & Education
Religion
Self Improvement
Sports
Technology & Science
Travel
Writing
Subscribe
Receive alert message from us when new articles submitted to our site for free.

Enter your name

Enter your email

Syndicate

















Related Products
Home::Entertainment

Do You Download Music Over A File-Sharing Network?

Author : Jason A. Martin
It can be estimated that millions of people around the world share music over a file-sharing network. For this article, I am addressing the issue in America mainly because I am not aware of the laws in other countries. Do you think it is illegal to download music from file-sharing networks? What about music you already own? An important recent court decision will answer these questions directly and you might be surprised.



Recently the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit heard a case against a Chicago woman, Cecilia Gonzalez. Many plaintiffs including BMG, Sony and others brought the case against her. Gonzalez allegedly had downloaded over 1,000 songs through KaZaA—although she admitted to only 30. Keep that number in mind, 30. Many, if not just about all, people who download files over a file-sharing network don’t stop at one file. Thirty files can be reached in minutes to an hour without thought. In fact, it was alleged that Gonzalez downloaded 1,370 songs in just a few weeks, which is an average of 65 songs per day.



If you where caught downloading thirty songs over a file-sharing network, what would your defense be? Let’s look at two specific common defenses and see how a court might react. I have selected two defenses that I feel are most common, because they not only appear in the court case I have referenced, but many others I have surveyed would try to use them as their defense as well.



First Defense: I was simply trying out the songs to see if I liked them and then I planned to buy the ones I liked and erase the ones I don’t. (Simplified: try-before-you-buy)



Judge Eastbrook, one of the judges hearing the Gonzalez case, pointed out that this defense is not valid because one had many avenues to hear music before purchasing. Eastbrook names iTunes, radio, internet radio, Yahoo! Music and others as ways to legally try before buying. If this was going to be your defense, you will lose.



Second Defense: I am only downloading music that I already own.



This seems like a great defense, at first. You already own the music and the law allows you to create a backup copy. Ah, but here is where it goes south. Downloading music you already own is not considered fair use under the U.S. Copyright Law and your action is therefore copyright infringement. See UMG Recordings Inc. v. MP3.com, Inc., 92 F. Supp. 2d 349.



Furthermore, the try-before-you-buy scenario is really blown away by the fact that you no longer need to buy CD’s in whole. iTunes really helped change the legal arena in this respect because a user can both sample songs at their leisure and purchase single songs. The ability to purchase single songs is the big one.



In the end, Gonzalez lost her case. The thirty songs, that would have cost $29.70 at iTunes, will end up costing her $22,500 in damages—imagine what it would be if the plaintiffs had pushed for a decision on all 1,370 songs. She was given the opportunity to settle for $3,500 before going to court, which she declined—another bad decision. If you download music over file-sharing networks and are caught, what will be your legal defense?


Article Source: http://www.articledashboard.com





Jason A. Martin is a Journalism Major (Political Science minor) and future law school student. His blog deals with Politics, Media and the Law. You can view it at JasonAMartin.com Subscribe!





Spam emails More free articles

Related articles


  1. Actor Samuel L. Jackson Launches a New Fan Friendly Website and Opens in "The Man" Friday September
  2. CAROLINE NADER AUSTRALIAN PHOTOGRAPHER RECEIVES HONOURABLE MENTION IN INTERNATIONAL PHOTOGRAPHY AWAR
  3. An interview with drummer Mykill(mike) aresco of Dead skin mask, pawns of christ and formerly of Los
  4. Learn to Play Guitar Online - Discover Guitar Lesson Tools.
  5. Robert Leroy Johnson..The King of the Delta Blues Lives on!
  6. Listening - A Question Of Studio Monitoring.
  7. Memories Are Made Of This : The Golden Years of The Sixties Music Revolution
  8. How to Download Music Online - The Right Way!
  9. Music Inside Us
  10. Ibanez Guitars At The 2006 NAMM Show
  11. Home recording studio
  12. Same old, and brand new, DVD talk!
  13. Rock DJ
  14. Music Therapy
  15. How Digital Light Processing is Slowly Conquering The TV Market
  16. Music : The Source, The Life Force
  17. Drum Tips - Why didn't you get the Gig?
  18. Drum Tips - Dealing with Bass Drum "Creep"
  19. Daddy Yankee
  20. What to look for in a Guitar Humidifier
  21. The History of Dolby Audio
  22. MP3 To CDA
  23. Make Your Own Beats, Instrumentals, Tracks, and Demo CDs
  24. Do You Download Music Over A File-Sharing Network?
  25. The Movie Rental – What Are You Doing Tonight?
More related feeds
Do You Download Music Over A File-Sharing Network?
It can be estimated that millions of people around the world share music over a file-sharing network. For this article, I am addressing the issue in America mainly because I am not aware of the laws in other countries. Do you think it ...

McAfee targets p2pnet. Again.
So when you see a Big Red X under the name of a site, what do you think? That it’s dodgy. Very dodgy. Why would McAfee single it out, otherwise? Last summer, “McAfee targets p2pnet,” said a p2pnet post. Today, August 28, 2008, ...

Do You Download Music Over a File-Sharing Network
sharing network. For this article, I am addressing the issue in America mainly because I am not aware of the laws in other countries. Do you think it is illegal to download music from file-sharing networks? What about music you already ...

Safe XP v1.5.7.14
safe for you if you do not use any HTML applications (HTA-files) at your computer. - Disable internal Java JIT compiler Disables Internet Explorer's internal Java Just-In-Time (JIT) compiler. - Disable Script Debugger ...

Telexy Networks SymSMB v3.50.22 S60v3 SymbianOS9.1 Unsigned arabic ...
browse network around your phone as you are used to from your favourite desktop; - get access to the network computers according to your rights and permissions; - map network drives for easy access; - do all from the above using any ...

Netgear RND4250 ReadyNAS NV+ 1 TB Desktop Network Storage (2×500GB)
It also automates the volume expansion for you as you scale from 1 hard drive to 4 hard drives. ReadyNAS allows you to start with one disk then add the additional drives over time without reconfiguring the system or shuffling the data. ...

File-sharing Networks Return with Legitimate Ways to Share Music ...
The service allowed anyone to swap -- or in the opinion of the major music labels, steal -- music files online. If you wanted a song by the White Stripes and someone on the network shared it, you could download and play it on your PC. ...

Do You Download Music Over a File-Sharing Network
... concern deal penalization over a file- distribution network. For this article, I am addressing the supply in USA mainly because I am not alive of the laws in another countries. Do you conceive it is banned to download penalization . ...

File sharing propaganda distributed to students
The story is simple: Megan learns to download music from a friend. About 2000 downloads and three months later, a police officer from the fictitious City of Arbor knocks on her door and hands her a criminal summons to appear in court. ...

Limewire Doubles Down on DRM-Free Music Store
Limewire, a popular file sharing application that offers users access to music, movie and other downloads via the decentralized gnutella network developed by Justin Frankel, the late Gene Kan and others, has more than doubled the size ...

 

 

2007 articlesreader.com - All Rights Reserved